Big cats are not new to Oklahoma. Mountain lions have been documented in the state since 1852 and listed as a game species since 1957. The Oklahoma Wildlife Department describes the cats this way:
“Its tail is more than half the length of the body, it has black tips on the tail and ears, and is primarily tan in color. The size of these animals varies by sex. Males average seven feet long (from nose to the tip of its tail) and weigh around 140 pounds, while females average six feet in length with a body weight around 95 pounds.”
The Oklahoma Wildlife Department also states that the best place to see a cat is extreme western Oklahoma; and yet, some of the most dramatic sightings have taking place in extreme
eastern Oklahoma.
Ray Harral Nature Park in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma (near Tulsa) closed in 2005 after a mountain lion reportedly took up residence there. Local schools were closed, authorities surrounded the park, and traps were set, but the cat was never caught. And even though this incident was reported in the Tulsa World newspaper--
"They saw a large, 100-pound cat-type animal," Pruden said. "They saw it come out of the woods, grab the dog and go back into the woods, making screeching, meowing sounds."
--no tracks, kills, or other signs of a physical animal were found in the park. The same year a “lion” terrorized the Battle Creek housing edition, also in Broken Arrow, reportedly devouring household pets. There was no speculation or confirmation on whether or not the same animal was responsible for both incidents. Like the Ray Harral lion, the Battle Creek cat was never caught.
In July 2007 goats, sheep, and chickens were attacked in Commerce, Oklahoma. A mountain lion was suggested as the culprit, but a cat was never seen.
While mountain lions are relatively rare, mountains lions in city areas like Broken Arrow even rarer, and lion attacks the rarest of all, these few out-of-place reports don’t necessarily point directly to paranormal activity.
Other reports, however, do.
In addition to the mountain lion, Oklahoma has bobcats and house cats roaming its hills. But report after report surfaces of cats that seem to be none of the three accepted species.
In March 1961 two “lions” were seen in Craig country and Vinta, Oklahoma. Not mountain lions—lions. African, one assumes.
Also in the 1960s, in the wilderness near Tulsa, a girl went to draw water from her well and was confronted with two “black panthers”, which sat and stared at her calmly.
A friend sent me this report via e-mail:
“Here is the description of the big cat that my mother saw the summer
before last (2007). If there is any details that I didn't include, just call
me and I will ask her!
It was a summer evening around 4 or 5pm in 2007 when Sandra Coppin
saw the big cat. She said that she stepped outside because the dogs
were barking. The cat was sitting calmly under some trees around 50
to 60 feet from the house. It was a stereotypical big cat in that it
was around 4 or 5 feet in length with a 2 inch tale as long as or
longer than its solid black body. She went back inside to tell her
husband that there was a huge cat outside. She looked back outside
just in time to see the cat stand up and walk into the nearby wooded
area.”
And then there is the thing I saw in the winter of last year (2008).
A friend and I were driving home from a bookstore in Broken Arrow—she was driving, I was in the passenger seat. It was dusk, but there was still enough light to see relatively clearly. The road was two-laned, with forest on one side and a school with a creek behind it on the other side. Something came out of the forest on the right side of the road—something I first thought was a dog, but it didn’t move like a dog. Its legs were thicker, its belly closer to the ground, and its stride more powerful than a dog. It crossed the road, and these were my impressions for those few seconds in the failing light: it was brown or tan, with very thick, long legs, a tail a little less than half the length of its body, and very, very long ears. It was definitely feline. And it was taller than the hood of the car (a Honda Accord). It loped across the road and vanished into the creek. My friend had also seen it, and she verified the details.
After the sighting we spent about an hour looking through pictures of the world’s known species of big cats. What we saw was not represented. The closest thing to it was a lynx, the big cat of Canada, and while a lynx in Oklahoma would be news in itself, the thing we saw wasn’t a lynx. It was only close to a lynx.
I’ve spent considerable time at Sequoyah State Park’s mini-zoo watching their resident caged bobcat, and the “cat that crossed the road” last year wasn’t a bobcat, either. It was also substantially different from a mountain lion.
An interesting note on black cats:
According to Wikipedia, “all-black coloring has never been documented on cougars…’black panther’ refers to melanistic individuals of other species, particularly jaguars and leopards.”
But jaguars and leopards don’t live here, or in the northeastern United States, Europe, or England, where large black cats are reported frequently. A completely black mountain lion has never been documented…and yet, 15-20% of cougar sightings are black (Gerry Parker,
The Eastern Puma, 1998 via Loren Coleman’s
Mysterious America, 2007).
Here is where I muse a little. Recall the infamous “Men in Black” written about by John Keel and others. They look like men, but their clothing or cars are fifty years out of date (but look brand new), or they are wearing clothing that hasn’t yet come into fashion. Or they speak strangely—a record speeded up or slowed down, or they don’t know how to use forks…or there’s just something off about them.
In addition to them we have cats—cats where there should not be, cats that are black and cats that leave tracks with claw marks (the only cat that walks with its claws out is the cheetah). Cats that fade away without a trace. Giant black grinning Cheshires.
Men who are not quite men. Cats that are not quite cats.
Connection?
Charles Fort would say, “one measure a circle, beginning anywhere”. Sherlock Holmes would say, “when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth”.
But then again, he’d also say, “It is a capital mistake to theorize before you have all the evidence. It biases the judgment."
~Y